It’s not that hard.
I’ve been scrolling through LinkedIn lately, and there’s a pattern that’s hard to ignore. Job applicants one after another, sharing their stories of complete radio silence after applying for a role.. Weeks of interviews followed by nothing. No email, no call, no acknowledgement they ever existed.
Both household names and smaller companies are equally guilty. The volume is increasing. The frustration is real. And honestly, it’s pretty embarrassing for our industry.
It’s clear that despite the constant ding-dong about it, very few companies really care about their employer brand. Some love the posturing and the virtue signalling, but most have zero interest.
The LinkedIn Reality Check
Five minutes on LinkedIn will show you what I mean. Candidates sharing their ghosting horror stories. Final-round interviews followed by absolute silence. Being told “we’ll be in touch by Friday” and then hearing nothing for months. Some never hear anything at all.
A mate put it perfectly recently: “Their incompetence comes across as contempt.”
That’s exactly what’s happening. What companies think is avoiding an awkward conversation, candidates experience as complete disrespect. The intent might be to avoid confrontation, but the impact is brutal.
Why This Matters Right Now
The candidates sharing these experiences aren’t being petty. They’re processing genuine disappointment and frustration. When someone invests weeks in your process, takes time off work for interviews, and prepares thoughtfully for conversations, they deserve to know where they stand. Even if it’s bad news.
The Bar Is Embarrassingly Low
The good news is that it’s incredibly easy to stand out because so many companies are doing absolutely nothing.
Whilst your competitors are ghosting candidates and pretending they never existed, you can differentiate yourself simply by sending a bloody email. The bar is so low that basic communication feels revolutionary.
What does “good enough” look like? Honestly, not much:
- Send some form of communication within a reasonable timeframe
- Acknowledge their investment in your process
- Be clear that you’re not moving forward
- Don’t make them chase you for an answer
That’s it. Nothing groundbreaking. Nothing expensive. Just basic professional courtesy that takes two minutes.
What Graceful Rejection Looks Like
Delivering rejection with grace isn’t complicated. It’s about being professional, clear, and human.
Early Stage Rejections: Be quick, clear, and contextual. Acknowledge the volume of applications without making excuses. Give them closure so they can move on.
Mid-Process Rejections: Reference your actual interactions. If they took a skills test or had a phone screen, discuss it. Show that a human reviewed their work, not just an algorithm.
Final Stage Rejections. This is where most companies catastrophically fail. After multiple interviews and weeks of the process, candidates deserve a phone call. A conversation shows respect for their investment and turns a disappointing experience into a demonstration of your values.
Thanks for reading this far – can you help me out?
- Share this with someone who might find it useful
- Subscribe if you haven’t already
- Consider upgrading to a paid subscription on Substack where you’ll get early access to podcasts, templates & AI prompts
These small actions help me keep building this resource. 👍
Thanks for being here, now on with the good stuff.
Pick Up the Phone
For candidates who’ve made it to final rounds, email isn’t enough. Make the call.
A phone call followed by a thoughtful email shows respect for their investment. It’s the difference between a LinkedIn complaint and a LinkedIn endorsement of your process.
Making It Stick
One good rejection email doesn’t create a reputation. Consistent patterns do. To systemise respectful rejection:
Create templates that don’t sound like templates. Give your team frameworks, but insist on customisation for each candidate.
Train your team on the why. Help them understand that rejection communication is brand management, not just admin work.
Follow through. If you offer feedback calls or future connections, deliver on them. Broken promises are worse than no promises.
Measure the impact. Pay attention to how candidates talk about your process publicly. Their LinkedIn posts are your report card.
The Reality
When you consistently deliver respectful rejections, candidates recommend your company to their networks, even after being rejected. Your process gets shared as an example of “how to do it right.” People become more willing to engage because they trust your approach.
Every rejection is a choice: damage your reputation or strengthen it. Add to the pile of LinkedIn complaint posts or become the company that gets praised for doing this right.
The volume of candidate frustration I’m seeing suggests most companies are making the wrong choice. But that creates an opportunity for the organisations willing to invest in basic human decency.
Whilst your competitors are generating LinkedIn complaint posts, you can be generating genuine goodwill. In a market where talent has choices, that’s not just nice to have, it’s a competitive advantage.
Get Started Today
To help you stop ghosting candidates immediately, I’ve created a complete set of recruitment email templates covering every stage from application acknowledgment through final rejections and offer calls.
These templates are free to take and customise. They include the language patterns, timing guidance, and rationale I’ve outlined above. Each template maintains the balance of being direct but respectful & specific but kind.
The templates cover application acknowledgments with timeline expectations, process updates when you’re running behind schedule, rejection communications at each interview stage, and proper interview booking emails that prepare candidates properly.
Please take them. Adapt them to your voice. And start treating basic communication as the brand-building opportunity it is.
What’s your experience with rejection communications? I’d love to hear your stories.
Before you go, can you help me out?
Over 1000 people have subscribed to this newsletter in under a month, which makes me feel that it’s resonating.
If you found this useful, here are three ways you could support me:
- Share it – Forward this to a founder, hiring manager, or job seeker who’d benefit
- Subscribe on Substack – Get early access to podcasts, templates, AI prompts, and bonus content at https://startuphiring.com.au/
- Send feedback – What topics would help you most? What’s working? What isn’t? Just hit reply.
I’m building this into the go-to resource for startup hiring. Whether you’re hiring your first employee or looking for your next role, I want this to be genuinely useful for you.
These small actions make a massive difference in helping me reach more people who need this content.
Thanks for being here. Have a brilliant week.
Weekly newsletter drops
- Monday 10:30am – Monday by the Numbers: Data-driven insights on startup hiring trends
- Wednesday 1:30pm – The Main Issue: Comprehensive guide with advice for teams & talent, plus The List and latest podcast
- Friday 10:30am – Hot Takes Friday: My unfiltered opinion on what’s happening in startup land
Need hiring help?
If you’re struggling with a specific hiring challenge, I still offer 1:1 strategy calls through my consultancy, Crew. Book a 15-minute clarity call here
Simon
